« March 2008 | Main | May 2008 »

April 24, 2008

sign now, clean up later (on someone else's watch)

It's one thing to sign laws cleaning up greenhouse gases after you leave office; it's another to oppose greenhouse gas sources that are almost on line, as Minnesota Governor Pawlenty is showing this week.

Gov. Tim Pawlenty won't speak out against a massive coal-burning power plant on Minnesota's western border, despite a request from one of the nation's most prominent and controversial climate scientists.

Dr. James Hansen, director of NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies, cited Pawlenty's leadership on greenhouse gas reduction in a letter this week that asked the governor to take a strong stand against construction of the proposed Big Stone II power plant in Milbank, S.D.

please, not again: back-door dealings on Dow?

This is giving Michigan a black eye. And 'dredging project' sounds so innocuous when you're actually talking about dumping dioxin-contaminated river junk in a disposal facility beside a river.

Michigan Lt. Gov. John Cherry has intervened in an Upper Saginaw River dredging project that could be delayed because of disagreements between state and federal regulators.

State and federal officials say Cherry's involvement may help settle differences between the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.

But at least one environmental group, the Lone Tree Council, fears a closed-door deal is in the works.

April 23, 2008

join the fight to clean up the Saginaw Bay

It's time to broaden the constituency for cleanup of one of the most contaminated hotspots in all of North America -- the Saginaw River Basin, tainted by Dow Chemical Company.

April 23, 2008  

The cleanup of Michigan’s largest Great Lakes Watershed will bring jobs and a brighter future for Michigan’s economy, and will benefit everyone who visits the Saginaw Bay Watershed and Lake Huron. An online petition is being used to gather signatures of as many of the millions of Great Lakes fans as possible – the simple message is that all of them support public participation in an open transparent process as the best way to assure a comprehensive cleanup of Dow Chemical’s dioxin to restore the entire region to health.

“We believe it is the duty of elected state lawmakers to uphold the public trust and protect and restore the Great Lakes to health,” states the petition. “Our economy, our public health, and our future depend on the exercise of this solemn obligation.”

Leaders of the Lone Tree Council, along with members of the Ecology Center of Ann Arbor, Sierra Club Michigan Chapter, Clean Water Action and the League of Conservation Voters traveled to Washington D.C. on February 26th for a meeting with top officials at the United States Environmental Protection Agency after learning of Dow’s request for a meeting with the agency.

“We were concerned that, as in the past, Dow Chemical was trying to slip behind closed doors to ask for a deal to avoid a cleanup of their dioxin,” Michelle Hurd-Riddick said. “So we decided to go to Washington, too, and make sure EPA knows there’s more than one stakeholder in this cleanup effort.” The groups met with Assistant Administrator Susan Bodine, head of EPA’s Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response and Superfund. At that meeting, Bodine confirmed the cleanup plan would not be altered. “Ms. Bodine told us that the Michigan DEQ will maintain the lead on corrective action cleanup, and EPA Region V will also be there,” said Riddick, “and that was very good to hear.”

To show there is support from the Great Lakes community for comprehensive cleanup of the dioxin in the watershed, the groups are asking Great Lakes fans to sign an online petition modeled after the position paper left with EPA, Assistant Administrator, Susan Bodine. Major community and environmental advocacy organizations have already signed on including the 70-member Michigan Environmental Council, but the groups want to show there is a larger audience.

Isle Royale Families and Friends site

Why is Isle Royale part of Michigan when it's 45 miles from Houghton, but only 15 from the Minnesota shoreline? There's interesting history behind that, but even better history on this web site, which contains stories and pictures of the people associated with one of the least-visited and most spectacular national parks in the U.S. The group's mission is to continue the over 100-year presence of family heritage, culture and rich human tradition on Isle Royale; to assure the preservation of historic family dwellings; to enhance the experience of [National Park Service] staf fby serving as authentic links to Isle Royale's rich human history.

 

slowly but surely, noose closing around Great Lakes aquatic invaders

A state district court judge in Ramsey County has ordered the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency to regulate ballast water released by Great Lakes ships as pollution.

April 22, 2008

Earth Day Michigan 1970: a look back in time

From Chapter 11 of Ruin and Recovery: Michigan's Rise as a Conservation Leader.

Wisconsin U.S. Senator Gaylord Nelson had proposed a national environmental “teach-in” on college campuses, urging that it become an opportunity for learning about the nation’s and world’s grave environmental problems. Fueled by campus activism, the teach-ins evolved into Earth Day and stunned skeptics. An estimated 10,000 schools, 2,000 colleges and universities and almost every community in the nation participated in events to celebrate and clean-up the environment. Cars were banned for two hours on Fifth  Avenue in New York City. The U.S. Congress adjourned for Earth Day so that members could attend teach-ins in their districts.

All three major TV networks covered the events around the country. A geology student attending Albion College, Walter Pomeroy, appeared on a CBS-TV prime-time special April 22, Earth Day: A Question of Survival, hosted by Walter Cronkite. In contrast to protests on other campuses that Cronkite called sometimes “frivolous,” the Albion activities Pomeroy organized included the cleanup of a vacant lot to create a small urban park. Albion called itself “Manufacturing City U.S.A.,” CBS reported, and not all its foundries had installed air pollution control equipment. But Pomeroy told reporter Hughes Rudd that he had arranged meetings with the local polluters to promote dialogue. “We were afraid,” he said, “that if we picketed the factories, it would actually turn the community against us.” The special showed Pomeroy’s fellow students jumping up and down on the non-aluminum cans they’d collected in the cleanup, making them easier to return to the manufacturer with a message that it should switch to recyclable materials.

Michigan television stations also broadcast specials in the season of Earth Day. WOOD-TV in Grand Rapids broadcast a series, Our Poisoned World, detailing serious local air, water and noise pollution and the problem of garbage disposal.

Michigan was one of the hotbeds of Earth Day action. At a five-day teach-in on the University of Michigan campus in in March, in which an estimated 50,000 persons participated, Victor Yannacone, who in 1967 had filed Environmental Defense Fund lawsuits to stop the spraying of DDT and dieldrin in Michigan, spoke on use of the courts to halt pollution. He told students, “This land is your land. It doesn’t belong to Ford, General Motors, or Chrysler…it doesn’t belong to any soulless corporation. It belongs to you and me.” A new student group called ENACT organized the week’s events, which included an “Environmental Scream-Out,” a tour of local pollution sites, music by popular singer Gordon Lightfoot and speeches by entertainer Arthur Godfrey, scientist Barry Commoner, consumer advocate Ralph Nader, and Senators Nelson and Edward Muskie of Maine.

Business Week magazine said the event had attracted the greatest turnout of any teach-in to that date. Noting that President Richard Nixon and college administrators hoped environmental issues would turn students away from Vietnam War protests, the magazine fretted that it appeared “the struggle for clean air and water is producing as many radicals as the war. And if the rhetoric at Michigan is any guide, business will bear the brunt of criticism.”

Action took different forms on different campuses. Tom Bailey, a Marquette high school student, worked with students at  Northern Michigan University to plan Earth Day activities. One was a “flush-in.” Students flushed fluorescent dye tablets down dorm toilets at a synchronized moment in an effort to prove that sewage was directly discharging into Lake Superior.

Events like these not only attracted the attention of the press, but also gave future environmental professionals their first major public exposure. Bailey later worked for the state Department of Natural Resources, as had his father, and became executive director of the Little Traverse Conservancy. One of ENACT’s founders on the University of Michigan campus, John Turner, later became director of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Doug Scott, a graduate student active in ENACT’s teach-in planning, moved on to the national staff of the Wilderness Society and the Sierra Club.  

Student concern and action did not stop on Earth Day. Walt Pomeroy of Albion College contacted activists on other campuses who agreed the next logical step was the formation of a student lobby for the environment. Described as “lobbyists in blue jeans” by one newspaper, the new Michigan Student Environmental Confederation received a surprisingly warm welcome from some in the Capitol.

“Soon we made friends in the legislature on both sides of the aisle,” said Pomeroy. “We learned a day at a time. And since we were in the Capitol almost every day, our network of friends and supporters expanded from just student groups to a diversity of community, environmental and sportsmen groups. Legislative priorities turned into victories…We started an environmental organization with a good cause, not much financial support and worked with the sportsmen and other environmental groups. We created the path – the opportunity – for others to also organize environmental groups and hire staff. None had existed solely to focus on state environmental legislative policies prior to the creation of MSEC. Many followed and are now part of the accepted political landscape."

it depends what the meaning of 'forever' is

Sadly, the Governor of Michigan has joined forces with private interests that want to convert a public park on Lake Michigan in Benton Harbor into a high-end country club. While nominally 'public,' the development will actually price out many people who now enjoy the beach at Jean Klock Park.

The benefits and demerits of the development can be argued in good faith. Jack Lessenberry's column goes to the heart of the issue, however. The land's donor 90 years ago provided it to the City of Benton Harbor with the stipulation that it forever be a public park and bathing beach. If 'forever' doesn't mean 'forever,' then all of the millions of acres of conservation easements that taxpayers and land conservancies have spent to secure forest, lakeshore, wetlands and other sensitive areas are in danger of being a hollow promise to future generations.

This development is not consistent with the donor's wishes, nor with the best interests of the State and the future.

April 21, 2008

MN provides startup funding for Upper Mississippi carp barrier

A $500,000 appropriation to assist with design of a barrier to thwart invasive species migrating up the Mississippi River became law recently when Gov. Pawlenty did not line-item veto it as he signed a $717 million bond bill.

“Prevention is better than cleanup,” says State Rep. Rick Hansen (D-South Saint Paul), who supported the project. “By preparing for this barrier, we hope to protect the Upper Mississippi and Minnesota River systems.”

Specifically, the bill language says the money should be used "to predesign and design an adequate barrier in the Mississippi River to prevent aquatic invasive species from migrating upriver. This money may be used by the commissioner to match available federal money and money from other states. The commissioner must inform and work with affected federal and state agencies and local communities along the Mississippi River before constructing the river barrier."

The bill is HF 380 and the final version (conference committee report) is available here. It's at the bottom of page 25.

the walleye run

Lake Erie's walleye run is the subject of this eloquent post about a mainstay of the Great Lakes fishery heritage.

One minor hitch is the heading:  Exploring the nature, history and culture of our Great Lake.

I'll get over my unrest about the idea that Erie is "our" Great Lake for Ohioans. I'll just assume the "our" refers to humanity, not Ohioans.

April 20, 2008

Madison museum shows off Great Lakes

Ah, some pleasant, hopeful Great Lakes news!

They also have a very cool large scale model of the great lakes which shows each lake, all of the large cities on the shores, major landmarks, and then fish and animals which inhabit each of the lakes. Very cool. There was even a rainstorm over Lake Ontario, mist over Lake Superior, and locks to open/close to allow ships through. We walked through the entire museum more than once - so much to see and do there.